Tuesday 23 July 2013

Freshers Moot Problem 2013


The Union of Bazingastan faced a heavy fiscal deficit in the last decade, due to which the Government enacted the Processing and Export of Meat Act, 2013 (PEMA). The Act encompassed all types of meat to be processed and exported to other countries. Soon this Act enabled the country to earn huge foreign exchange and consequently it became the world’s top exporter of buffalo meat.  It opened up a new sector of occupation, which reduced unemployment to a great degree. The Union of Bazingastan defended the Act as the new “Pink Revolution” and assured the citizens that the state had enough live stock for internal consumption. The state also ensured that no cruelty towards the animals was practiced and to this effect certified safety standards were upheld.
On the other hand, various other states witnessed large-scale slaughtering of cattle. Moreover, the manner in which the animals were transported and slaughtered fell way below international standards. An NGO by the name of People for Moral Treatment of Animals (PMTA) filed a petition in the Hon’ble Supreme Court challenging the constitutional validity of the Act.  The PMTA raised concerns about the said Act as the slaughter of animals on such a large scale deprived the nation of dung availability which in turn affects agriculture. Also, the use of chemical fertilizers damages the fertility of the soil.

*Note- 
·        Participants are expected to prepare their arguments for both sides.
·       The laws of Bazingastan are in pari materia those of India.
:


Dr. Geeta Kubsad                                                                 

Faculty in-charge